lux/docs/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md

Lux Language Implementation Plan

Current Status Summary

What's Working (222 tests passing)

Core Language:

• Lexer and parser for core syntax
• AST representation
• Type checker with Hindley-Milner inference
• Interpreter with REPL
• Tail call optimization (TCO)
• Pattern matching with exhaustiveness checking
• Algebraic data types (ADTs) with constructors
• Records and tuples
• Higher-order functions and closures
• Pipe operator (|>)
• Documentation comments
• Generic type parameters (fn map<T, U>, type List<T>)
• String interpolation ("Hello {name}!")
• Escape sequences (\n, \t, \", \{, \})

Effect System:

• Effect declarations
• Effect signatures on functions (with {Effect})
• Handler definitions
• run ... with syntax
• Effect inference within function bodies
• Effect subset checking (pure functions callable in effectful contexts)

Built-in Effects:

• Console - print, readLine, readInt
• File - read, write, exists, delete, listDir, createDir
• Http - get, post, put, delete (HTTP client)
• HttpServer - listen, accept, respond, respondWithHeaders, stop (HTTP server)
• Random - int, float, range, bool, element
• Time - now, sleep

Type Classes:

• Trait declarations
• Implementation blocks
• Basic trait method dispatch

Behavioral Properties:

• Property declarations (is pure, is idempotent, is total, is deterministic, is commutative)
• Property parsing and storage in AST
• Pure function verification (no effects allowed)
• Deterministic verification (no Random/Time effects)
• Commutative verification (operator-based analysis)
• Idempotent verification (pattern-based analysis)
• Total verification (structural recursion, termination checking)

Module System:

• Import/export with pub visibility
• Aliased imports (import foo as bar)
• Selective imports (import foo.{a, b})
• Wildcard imports (import foo.*)
• Circular dependency detection
• Transitive imports

JIT Compiler (Cranelift):

• Integer arithmetic and comparisons
• Conditionals, let bindings, blocks
• Function calls including recursion
• ~160x speedup over interpreter for numeric code
• CLI integration via lux compile <file>

Standard Library:

• String operations (substring, length, split, trim, etc.)
• List operations (map, filter, fold, etc.)
• JSON parsing and serialization
• Math functions

Tooling:

• REPL with history and autocomplete
• LSP server (diagnostics, hover, completions)
• Watch mode for auto-recompilation
• Source-context error messages

Example Programs Working

1. hello.lux - Basic effect usage
2. factorial.lux - Recursion
3. effects.lux - Custom effects and handlers
4. datatypes.lux - ADTs and pattern matching
5. functional.lux - Higher-order functions
6. traits.lux - Type classes
7. behavioral.lux - Behavioral properties
8. tailcall.lux - Tail call optimization
9. statemachine.lux - State machines with ADTs
10. pipelines.lux - Pipe operator
11. generics.lux - Generic type parameters
12. json.lux - JSON parsing and serialization
13. jit_test.lux - JIT compilation demo
14. guessing_game.lux - Console input/output
15. http_server.lux - HTTP server with routing
16. examples/modules/main.lux - Module imports
17. examples/modules/main_selective.lux - Selective imports
18. examples/modules/main_wildcard.lux - Wildcard imports

---

Missing Features Analysis

Priority 1: Critical Missing Features

1.1 Generic Type Parameters

Status: ✅ Complete

Generic type parameters are fully working:

• Type parameter declarations in type definitions (type List<T> = ...)
• Generic function parameters (fn map<T, U>(f: fn(T): U, list: List<T>): List<U>)
• Type application and instantiation
• See examples/generics.lux for working examples

Still Missing (nice-to-have):

• Type parameter constraints (where T: Eq)

1.2 String Interpolation

Status: ✅ Complete

String interpolation is fully working:

• "Hello, {name}!" syntax
• Nested expressions: "Result: {1 + 2}"
• Escape sequences: \{, \}, \n, \t, \", \\

1.3 Better Error Messages

Status: ⚠️ Partial

What's Working:

• Source code context with line/column numbers
• Caret pointing to error location
• Color-coded error output

What's Missing:

• Type diff display for mismatches
• "Did you mean?" suggestions
• Error recovery in parser

Implementation Steps:

1. Add Levenshtein distance for suggestions
2. Implement error recovery in parser
3. Add type diff visualization

Priority 2: Effect System Completion

2.1 Effect Polymorphism

Status: Not implemented.

What's Missing:

• Functions generic over their effects
• Effect variables in type signatures
• Effect constraints

Example syntax:

fn withRetry<E>(action: fn(): T with E, attempts: Int): T with E = ...

Implementation Steps:

1. Add effect variables to effect representation
2. Implement effect unification with variables
3. Support effect quantification in type schemes

2.2 Built-in Effects

Status: ✅ Core effects complete

Working Effects:

• Console - print, readLine, readInt
• File - read, write, exists, delete, listDir, createDir
• Http - get, post, put, delete (HTTP client)
• HttpServer - listen, accept, respond, respondWithHeaders, stop
• Random - int, float, range, bool, element
• Time - now, sleep
• State - get, put (built-in)
• Reader - ask (built-in)

Missing Effects (nice-to-have):

• Async - async/await pattern
• Generic effect parameters (State<S>)

2.3 Resumable Handlers

Status: Handlers exist but may not support continuation resumption.

What's Missing:

• resume keyword to continue computation
• Multi-shot continuations
• Proper effect handler semantics

Priority 3: Schema Evolution

3.1 Versioned Types

Status: ✅ Type system integration complete

What's Working:

• Version annotations preserved in type system (Int @v1, User @v2)
• Version mismatch detection at compile time
• Version constraints: @v1 (exact), @v2+ (at least), @latest (any)
• Versioned type declarations tracked
• Migration bodies stored for future execution

Still Missing (nice-to-have):

• Auto-migration generation
• Version-aware serialization/codecs

Priority 4: Module System

4.1 Complete Import/Export

Status: ✅ Complete.

The module system is fully functional with:

• import foo/bar - basic imports
• import foo/bar as alias - aliased imports
• import foo.{a, b} - selective imports
• import foo.* - wildcard imports
• pub fn visibility for exports
• Circular dependency detection (tested)
• Module caching
• Transitive imports
• Type checking across modules

Still Missing (nice-to-have):

• Re-exports (pub import)
• Package manifest (package.lux)

Priority 5: Code Generation

5.1 Compile to Target

Status: ⚠️ Partial - JIT works for numeric code

What's Working:

• src/compiler.rs - Cranelift JIT compiler (539 lines)
• Integer arithmetic, comparisons, boolean ops
• Conditionals, let bindings, function calls, blocks
• Recursive functions (fib(30) compiles and runs)
• CLI integration: lux compile <file> [--benchmark]
• ~160x speedup over interpreter for numeric code

What's Missing in JIT:

• Strings, floats, lists, records, tuples
• Pattern matching, ADTs
• Effects and handlers

Target Options for Full Compilation:

1. WASM - Best for web and portable deployment
2. JavaScript - Easiest web integration
3. Extend Cranelift - Build on existing JIT

Implementation Steps:

1. Expose JIT via CLI command ✅ Done
2. Add support for more types (strings, lists, etc.)
3. Compile pattern matching
4. Handle effects (CPS transform or evidence passing)

Priority 6: Tooling

6.1 Package Manager

What's Needed:

• Package registry
• Dependency resolution
• Version management
• Build system integration

6.2 Standard Library

What's Needed:

• Collections (Map, Set, Array)
• String utilities
• Math functions
• File I/O
• Network I/O
• JSON/YAML parsing

6.3 Debugger

What's Needed:

• Breakpoints
• Step execution
• Variable inspection
• Stack traces

---

Recommended Implementation Order

Phase 1: Language Completeness (Essential)

1. Generic type parameters ✅ Done
2. String interpolation ✅ Done
3. Better error messages - Elm-quality suggestions

Phase 2: Effect System Maturity

4. Built-in effects (Console, File, Http, Random, Time) ✅ Done
5. Effect polymorphism - Generic effect parameters
6. Fail effect - Proper error handling pattern
7. Resumable handlers - Multi-shot continuations

Phase 3: Production Readiness

8. Complete module system ✅ Done
9. Standard library basics ✅ Done (String, List, JSON)
10. Package manager - Dependency resolution
11. Full compilation - Extend JIT or add WASM/JS backend

Phase 4: Behavioral Types (Verification)

12. Total function verification ✅ Done - Termination checking
13. Idempotent verification ✅ Done - Pattern-based analysis
14. Deterministic verification ✅ Done - Effect-based analysis
15. Commutative verification ✅ Done - Operator analysis
16. Where clause enforcement - Constraint checking (basic parsing done)

Phase 5: Schema Evolution (Data)

17. Type system version tracking ✅ Done
18. Version mismatch detection ✅ Done
19. Auto-migration generation - Generate migration code
20. Version-aware serialization - Codecs

Phase 6: Advanced Features

18. Refinement types - SMT solver integration
19. Async/await effect
20. Stream processing

---

Technical Debt

Known Issues Fixed During Testing

1. ✅ String concatenation with + operator wasn't type-checked correctly
2. ✅ ADT constructors weren't registered in type environment
3. ✅ ADT constructors weren't registered in interpreter environment
4. ✅ Handlers weren't accessible as values
5. ✅ Effect checking was too strict (required exact match instead of subset)
6. ✅ total keyword conflicts with variable names in examples

Remaining Technical Debt

1. Dead code in diagnostics, modules, parser (suppressed with #![allow(dead_code)])
2. Some test utilities not fully utilized
3. LSP server basic but could be expanded
4. Error recovery in parser incomplete

---

Feature Comparison with Other Languages

Feature	Lux	Koka	Haskell	Rust	TypeScript
Algebraic Effects	✅	✅	Via libs	❌	❌
Type Inference	✅	✅	✅	Partial	Partial
ADTs	✅	✅	✅	✅	Via unions
Pattern Matching	✅	✅	✅	✅	Limited
Generics	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅
Type Classes	Basic	✅	✅	✅	❌
String Interpolation	✅	✅	❌	❌	✅
Effect Polymorphism	❌	✅	Via mtl	N/A	N/A
Schema Evolution	✅	❌	❌	❌	❌
Behavioral Types	✅	❌	❌	❌	❌
HTTP Server	✅	❌	Via libs	Via libs	Via libs
Refinement Types	Planned	❌	Via LH	❌	❌
Tail Call Opt	✅	✅	✅	Limited	❌
JIT Compilation	⚠️ Numeric	✅	✅	N/A	N/A
REPL	✅	✅	✅	Limited	✅
LSP	Basic	✅	✅	✅	✅

---

Unique Value Proposition

Lux differentiates itself through:

1. First-class algebraic effects - Making side effects explicit, testable, and composable
2. Schema evolution - Type-safe version tracking with compile-time mismatch detection
3. Behavioral types - Compile-time verification of purity, totality, determinism, idempotency
4. Built-in HTTP server - Effect-tracked web servers without external frameworks
5. Developer experience - Elm-style errors, REPL, LSP support

The combination of these features makes Lux particularly suited for:

• Building reliable backend services with explicit effect tracking
• Applications with complex state management
• Systems requiring careful versioning and migration
• Projects where testing and verification are critical
• Educational use for learning algebraic effects