Files
lux/PACKAGES.md
Brandon Lucas 4909ff9fff docs: add package ecosystem plan and error documentation workflow
Add PACKAGES.md analyzing the Lux package ecosystem gaps vs stdlib,
with prioritized implementation plans for markdown, xml, rss, frontmatter,
path, and sitemap packages. Add CLAUDE.md instructions for documenting
Lux language errors in ISSUES.md during every major task.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-18 10:01:56 -05:00

368 lines
12 KiB
Markdown

# Lux Package Ecosystem Plan
## Current State
### Stdlib (built-in)
| Module | Coverage |
|--------|----------|
| String | Comprehensive (split, join, trim, indexOf, replace, etc.) |
| List | Good (map, filter, fold, head, tail, concat, range, find, any, all, take, drop) |
| Option | Basic (map, flatMap, getOrElse, isSome, isNone) |
| Result | Basic (map, flatMap, getOrElse, isOk, isErr) |
| Math | Basic (abs, min, max, sqrt, pow, floor, ceil, round) |
| Json | Comprehensive (parse, stringify, get, typed extractors, constructors) |
| File | Good (read, write, append, exists, delete, readDir, isDir, mkdir) |
| Console | Good (print, read, readLine, readInt) |
| Process | Good (exec, execStatus, env, args, exit, cwd) |
| Http | Basic (get, post, put, delete, setHeader) |
| HttpServer | Basic (listen, accept, respond) |
| Time | Minimal (now, sleep) |
| Random | Basic (int, float, bool) |
| Sql | Good (SQLite: open, query, execute, transactions) |
| Postgres | Good (connect, query, execute, transactions) |
| Schema | Niche (versioned data migration) |
| Test | Good (assert, assertEqual, assertTrue) |
| Concurrent | Experimental (spawn, await, yield, cancel) |
| Channel | Experimental (create, send, receive) |
### Registry (pkgs.lux) - 3 packages
| Package | Version | Notes |
|---------|---------|-------|
| json | 1.0.0 | Wraps stdlib Json with convenience functions (getPath, getString, etc.) |
| http-client | 0.1.0 | Wraps stdlib Http with JSON helpers, URL encoding |
| testing | 0.1.0 | Wraps stdlib Test with describe/it structure |
---
## Gap Analysis
### What's Missing vs Other Languages
Compared to ecosystems like Rust/cargo, Go, Python, Elm, Gleam:
| Category | Gap | Impact | Notes |
|----------|-----|--------|-------|
| **Collections** | No HashMap, Set, Queue, Stack | Critical | List-of-pairs with O(n) lookup is the only option |
| **Sorting** | No List.sort or List.sortBy | High | Must implement insertion sort manually |
| **Date/Time** | Only `Time.now()` (epoch ms), no parsing/formatting | High | blu-site does string-based date formatting manually |
| **Markdown** | No markdown parser | High | blu-site has 300+ lines of hand-rolled markdown |
| **XML/RSS** | No XML generation | High | Can't generate RSS feeds or sitemaps |
| **Regex** | No pattern matching on strings | High | Character-by-character scanning required |
| **Path** | No file path utilities | Medium | basename/dirname manually reimplemented |
| **YAML/TOML** | No config file parsing (beyond JSON) | Medium | Frontmatter parsing is manual |
| **Template** | No string templating | Medium | HTML built via raw string concatenation |
| **URL** | No URL parsing/encoding | Medium | http-client has basic urlEncode but no parser |
| **Crypto** | No hashing (SHA256, etc.) | Medium | Can't do checksums, content hashing |
| **Base64** | No encoding/decoding | Low | Needed for data URIs, some auth |
| **CSV** | No CSV parsing | Low | Common data format |
| **UUID** | No UUID generation | Low | Useful for IDs |
| **Logging** | No structured logging | Low | Just Console.print |
| **CLI** | No argument parsing library | Low | Manual arg handling |
### What Should Be Stdlib vs Package
**Should be stdlib additions** (too fundamental to be packages):
- HashMap / Map type (requires runtime support)
- List.sort / List.sortBy (fundamental operation)
- Better Time module (date parsing, formatting)
- Regex (needs runtime/C support for performance)
- Path module (cross-platform file path handling)
**Should be packages** (application-level, opinionated, composable):
- markdown
- xml
- rss/atom
- frontmatter
- template
- csv
- crypto
- ssg (static site generator framework)
---
## Priority Package Plans
Ordered by what unblocks blu-site fixes first, then general ecosystem value.
---
### Package 1: `markdown` (Priority: HIGHEST)
**Why:** The 300-line markdown parser in blu-site's main.lux is general-purpose code that belongs in a reusable package. It's also the most complex part of blu-site and has known bugs (e.g., `### ` inside list items renders literally).
**Scope:**
```
markdown/
lux.toml
lib.lux # Public API: parse, parseInline
src/
inline.lux # Inline parsing (bold, italic, links, images, code)
block.lux # Block parsing (headings, lists, code blocks, blockquotes, hr)
types.lux # AST types (optional - could emit HTML directly)
```
**Public API:**
```lux
// Convert markdown string to HTML string
pub fn toHtml(markdown: String): String
// Convert inline markdown only (no blocks)
pub fn inlineToHtml(text: String): String
// Escape HTML entities
pub fn escapeHtml(s: String): String
```
**Improvements over current blu-site code:**
- Fix heading-inside-list-item rendering (`- ### Title` should work)
- Support nested lists (currently flat only)
- Support reference-style links `[text][ref]`
- Handle edge cases (empty lines in code blocks, nested blockquotes)
- Proper HTML entity escaping in more contexts
**Depends on:** Nothing (pure string processing)
**Estimated size:** ~400-500 lines of Lux
---
### Package 2: `xml` (Priority: HIGH)
**Why:** Needed for RSS/Atom feed generation, sitemap.xml, and robots.txt generation. General-purpose XML builder that doesn't try to parse XML (which would need regex), just emits it.
**Scope:**
```
xml/
lux.toml
lib.lux # Public API: element, document, serialize
```
**Public API:**
```lux
type XmlNode =
| Element(String, List<XmlAttr>, List<XmlNode>)
| Text(String)
| CData(String)
| Comment(String)
| Declaration(String, String) // version, encoding
type XmlAttr =
| Attr(String, String)
// Build an XML element
pub fn element(tag: String, attrs: List<XmlAttr>, children: List<XmlNode>): XmlNode
// Build a text node (auto-escapes)
pub fn text(content: String): XmlNode
// Build a CDATA section
pub fn cdata(content: String): XmlNode
// Serialize XML tree to string
pub fn serialize(node: XmlNode): String
// Serialize with XML declaration header
pub fn document(version: String, encoding: String, root: XmlNode): String
// Convenience: self-closing element
pub fn selfClosing(tag: String, attrs: List<XmlAttr>): XmlNode
```
**Depends on:** Nothing
**Estimated size:** ~150-200 lines
---
### Package 3: `rss` (Priority: HIGH)
**Why:** Directly needed for blu-site's #6 priority fix (add RSS feed). Builds on `xml` package.
**Scope:**
```
rss/
lux.toml # depends on xml
lib.lux # Public API: feed, item, toXml, toAtom
```
**Public API:**
```lux
type FeedInfo =
| FeedInfo(String, String, String, String, String)
// title, link, description, language, lastBuildDate
type FeedItem =
| FeedItem(String, String, String, String, String, String)
// title, link, description, pubDate, guid, categories (comma-separated)
// Generate RSS 2.0 XML string
pub fn toRss(info: FeedInfo, items: List<FeedItem>): String
// Generate Atom 1.0 XML string
pub fn toAtom(info: FeedInfo, items: List<FeedItem>): String
```
**Depends on:** `xml`
**Estimated size:** ~100-150 lines
---
### Package 4: `frontmatter` (Priority: HIGH)
**Why:** blu-site has ~50 lines of fragile frontmatter parsing. This is a common need for any content-driven Lux project. The current parser uses `String.indexOf(line, ": ")` which breaks on values containing `: `.
**Scope:**
```
frontmatter/
lux.toml
lib.lux # Public API: parse
```
**Public API:**
```lux
type FrontmatterResult =
| FrontmatterResult(List<(String, String)>, String)
// key-value pairs, remaining body
// Parse frontmatter from a string (--- delimited YAML-like header)
pub fn parse(content: String): FrontmatterResult
// Get a value by key from parsed frontmatter
pub fn get(pairs: List<(String, String)>, key: String): Option<String>
// Get a value or default
pub fn getOrDefault(pairs: List<(String, String)>, key: String, default: String): String
// Parse a space-separated tag string into a list
pub fn parseTags(tagString: String): List<String>
```
**Improvements over current blu-site code:**
- Handle values with `: ` in them (only split on first `: `)
- Handle multi-line values (indented continuation)
- Handle quoted values with embedded newlines
- Strip quotes from values consistently
**Depends on:** Nothing
**Estimated size:** ~100-150 lines
---
### Package 5: `path` (Priority: MEDIUM)
**Why:** blu-site manually implements `basename` and `dirname`. Any file-processing Lux program needs these. Tiny but universally useful.
**Scope:**
```
path/
lux.toml
lib.lux
```
**Public API:**
```lux
// Get filename from path: "/foo/bar.txt" -> "bar.txt"
pub fn basename(p: String): String
// Get directory from path: "/foo/bar.txt" -> "/foo"
pub fn dirname(p: String): String
// Get file extension: "file.txt" -> "txt", "file" -> ""
pub fn extension(p: String): String
// Remove file extension: "file.txt" -> "file"
pub fn stem(p: String): String
// Join path segments: join("foo", "bar") -> "foo/bar"
pub fn join(a: String, b: String): String
// Normalize path: "foo//bar/../baz" -> "foo/baz"
pub fn normalize(p: String): String
// Check if path is absolute
pub fn isAbsolute(p: String): Bool
```
**Depends on:** Nothing
**Estimated size:** ~80-120 lines
---
### Package 6: `sitemap` (Priority: MEDIUM)
**Why:** Directly needed for blu-site's #9 priority fix. Simple package that generates sitemap.xml.
**Scope:**
```
sitemap/
lux.toml # depends on xml
lib.lux
```
**Public API:**
```lux
type SitemapEntry =
| SitemapEntry(String, String, String, String)
// url, lastmod (ISO date), changefreq, priority
// Generate sitemap.xml string
pub fn generate(entries: List<SitemapEntry>): String
// Generate a simple robots.txt pointing to the sitemap
pub fn robotsTxt(sitemapUrl: String): String
```
**Depends on:** `xml`
**Estimated size:** ~50-70 lines
---
### Package 7: `ssg` (Priority: LOW - future)
**Why:** Once markdown, frontmatter, rss, sitemap, and path packages exist, the remaining logic in blu-site's main.lux is generic SSG framework code: read content dirs, parse posts, sort by date, generate section indexes, generate tag pages, copy static assets. This could be extracted into a framework package that other Lux users could use to build their own static sites.
**This should wait** until the foundation packages above are stable and battle-tested through blu-site usage.
---
## Non-Package Stdlib Improvements Needed
These gaps are too fundamental to be packages and should be added to the Lux language itself:
### HashMap (Critical)
Every package above that needs key-value lookups (frontmatter, xml attributes, etc.) is working around the lack of HashMap with `List<(String, String)>`. This is O(n) per lookup and makes code verbose. A stdlib `Map` module would transform the ecosystem.
### List.sort / List.sortBy (High)
blu-site implements insertion sort manually. Every content-driven app needs sorting. This should be a stdlib function.
### Time.format / Time.parse (High)
blu-site manually parses "2025-01-15" by substring extraction and maps month numbers to names. A proper date/time library (even just ISO 8601 parsing and basic formatting) would help every package above.
---
## Implementation Order
```
Phase 1 (unblock blu-site fixes):
1. markdown - extract from blu-site, fix bugs, publish
2. frontmatter - extract from blu-site, improve robustness
3. path - tiny, universally useful
4. xml - needed by rss and sitemap
Phase 2 (complete blu-site features):
5. rss - depends on xml
6. sitemap - depends on xml
Phase 3 (ecosystem growth):
7. template - string templating (mustache-like)
8. csv - data processing
9. cli - argument parsing
10. ssg - framework extraction from blu-site
```
Each package should be developed in its own directory under `~/src/`, published to the git.qrty.ink registry, and tested by integrating it into blu-site.